Chianti Classico Grand Tasting NYC 2025

On April 28th the Consorzio Vino Chianti Classico held a tasting of the wines of Chianti Classico Black Rooster label. They brought over 39 wineries to pour current and older vintages of their wines and Vin Santo and local olive oils.

The tasting was held at Manhatta restaurant located at 39 Liberty Street in lower Manhattan.

Chianti is probably the most well know Italian wine and Chianti Classico with the Black Rooster label is the most well know of the eight Chianti regions. In addition to Classico, the rest of the regions are Montalbano, Rufina, Montespertoli, Colline Pisane, Colli Aretini and Colli Fiorentini.

Chianti Classico was born in 1716 when the borders of the production zone were delimited.

There are three tiers on the quality pyramid of Chianti. The first is Annata, the next tier up is Riserva and the top tier which is about 6% of Chianti Classico production is the Gran Selezione, a new category that was established in 2014. The requirements have 80%-90% minimum to 100% maximum of Sangiovese to be used with the rest indigenous or international red grapes.

At a large tasting I focus my efforts and today I sampled the Riserva wines from the various wineries.

2016 Tenuta Carobbio Chianti Classico Riserva “Carobbio:” Clear dark brick, woody dark chocolate on the nose, chewy fruit with forest floor notes ending with firm, silky tannin.

2017 Tenuta Carobbio Chianti Classico Riserva “Carobbio”: Clear medium brick, sweet tar and rosemary on the nose, sweet dusty fruit ending with bitter almond notes, nice grip.

2018 Quercia al Poggio Chianti Classico “Quercia al Poggio”: Clear medium brick, sweet dirty tar on the nose, tight with bitter cherry notes.

2019 Caparsa Chianti Classico Riserva “Pietraia”: Opaque dark red, sweet tar and white pepper on the nose, concentrated ripe fruit, firm tannin.

2020 Casina di Cornia Chianti Classico Riserva “Vigna la Casina”: Clear medium brick, forest floor and red fruit on the nose, dusty red fruit ending with silky, firm tannins.

2020 Borgo Scopeto Chianti Classico Riserva “Vigna Misciano”: Clear light red, closed nose of sweet stone, juicy red fruit with dusty tannin.

2020 Melini Vigneti La Selvanella Chianti Classico Riserva ” Vigneti La Selvanella”: Clear medium brick, smoky black cherry on the nose, concentrated dusty fruit firm tannin and acids at the finish.

2020 Castello Monterinaldi Chianti Classico Riserva “Castello Monterinaldi”: Clear medium brick, smoke and tar on the nose, tight red fruit, firm tannin.

2021 Castello di Monsanto Chianti Classico Riserva “Castello di Monsanto”: Clear medium purple, toasty smoke on the nose, tight and dusty fruit, firm tannin.

2021 Ormanni Chianti Classico Riserva “Borro del Diavolo”: Clear medium brick, tarry dirt on the nose, chewy dusty fruit, nice grip.

2022 Vallepicciola Chianti Classico Riserva “Vallepicciola”: Clear medium brick, sweet gun metal on the nose, tight and concentrated crushed black fruit with black pepper and bitter cherry notes at the finish.

2022 Marchesi Frescobaldi Chianti Classico Riserva “Tenuta Perano”: Opaque dark purple, sweet tar and leather on the nose, tight and dusty red fruit ending with citrus notes and firm tannin.

Chianti Classico Book Seminar

On February 6, I attended a talk given by Alessandro Masnaghetti who wrote a newly published book on Chianti Classico.

The lecture was held at the offices of Baneville Wine Merchants located at 126 East 38th Street in midtown Manhattan.

It’s a big book with a lot of detail for that district of Chianti. I did learn what a UGA (Unita Geografiche Aggiuntive) is which are officially delimited subzones within a Chianti subzone.

As part of the lecture, we tasted five Chianti from five of those UGA subzones. They were from the 2020 vintage and were drinking nicely.

2020 Cigliano Di Sopra (San Casciano): Clear medium purple, dusty tar. graphite and earth on the nose, concentrated dusty bright red fruit with crushed rock notes on the finish.

2020 I Fabbri “La Mole” (Lamole): Clear medium brick, dusty nose of green stems and rocks, juicy red fruit and black licorice ending with a mouthful of tannins.

2020 Fattoria Le Masse (San Donato in Poggio): Clear medium red, big perfume of sweet crushed red fruit and some earth, concentrated silky black fruit with dusty leather notes on the long and balanced finish. My favorite of the flight.

2020 Tolaini “Mello” (Gaiole): Clear red with a perfume of violets and roast meat, tight red fruit with firm tannins and a long finish.

2020 Tolaini “Vallenuova” (Castelnuova Beradenga): Opaque dark red, perfume of tar, red leather and sweet fruit with dusty, silky red fruit with a good grip and a nice balance. Another favorite of the tasting.

I.E.E.M. Chianti Classico Collection

On May 20 & 21st the I.E.E.M. (International Event & Exhibition Management) held another of its series of tastings where they showcase a particular wine to wine professionals and look for importers/distributor for the wines. This time around it was the Chianti Classico Collection. They were wines from the Black Rooster (gallo nero) Chianti Classico DOCG in Tuscany.

There are seven subzones in the Chianti DOCG, Colli Arentini, Colli Fiorentini, Colli Senesi, Colli Pisane, Rufina, Montespertoli and Montalano. Classico was a subzone but became its own DOCG in 1996.

This was a live tasting but modified for current conditions. You sat at a table and via smartphone would order 4 wines from their 200+ bottle list on hand and a Sommelier would come over and pour the wines.

It was a vertical tasting of the 2015-2019 vintages and all of the three quality tiers were represented including Gran Selezione, Riserva and the basic Classico. The formula for Chianti has changed in recent years and they are no longer required to use a small percentage of white grapes and they can now use foreign varietals such as Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon.

In general, of the five vintages I would say that the 2016’s were showing well with the strongest concentration of fruit from the vintages. The 2019’s were for the most part still young and unbalanced, these are some of my highlights.

2015 Cantina Castelvecchi “Madonnino della Pieve” Gran Selezione: Opaque dark red, pretty perfume of sweet violets, tar and dried sage, silky fruit with firm tannins on the medium to long finish.

2015 Castello di Radda “Vigna il Corno”Gran Selezione: Clear medium brick, closed nose of toasted nuts with red cherry fruit and gritty, mouth coating tannins at the end.

2015 Piemaggio “Le Fioraie”: Riserva: Clear light red, red licorice, mint and violets on the nose, earth notes on the bright fruit, firm finish.

2015 Castello di Raddo Riserva: Light brick, closed nose of cooked vegetables, juicy black licorice fruit ending with a firm and balanced long finish.

2015 Istine “Levigne” Riserva: Clear light red, closed nose of dried herbs, bright red fruit with slate and toast notes, ending with firm tannins.

2016 Agricoltori del Chianti “Contessa di Radda” Riserva: Opaque dark red with a purple rim with crushed red fruit on the nose, juicy with toasty notes on the fruit.

2016 Castello di Verrazzano Riserva: Clear dark brick in color, sweet violets and dried herbs on the nose, dusty earth on the fruit with firm tannins.

2016 Canoica a Cerreto Riserva: Clear medium red with dried leaf on the nose, tight with mouth coating tannins.

2016 Agricoltori del Chianti “Montegiachi” Riserva: Clear dark red, perfume of violets and roasted meat, concentrate dark fruit with slate notes, nice balance with dried herbs on the long finish.

2016 Castello di Radda Riserva: Clear medium red, tar, roasted nuts and camphor on the nose, juicy fruit with silky tannins, nice balance.

2017 Banfi Riserva: Opaque medium brick, pretty sweet nose, starts out with juicy fruit that drops at the end with black licorice notes.

2017 Brancaia Riserva: Clear medium red with roasted nuts on the nose, firm red fruit and a balanced finish.

2018 Badia & Coltibuono Classico: Clear light brick, pencil shavings and forest floor on the nose, delicate and light bodied.

2018 Pasolini dall’Onda “Sicelle” Classico: Clear medium red with toasted notes on the nose with silky fruit and a nice a nice balance.

2018 Castello di Radda Classico: Clear medium red, pretty nose of violets, tar, graphite with moderate to light fruit and light tannins at the end.

2019 Marchese Antinori “Peppoli” Classico: Clear light red with dried herbs on the nose, bright fruit.

2019 Felsina “Beradenga” Chianti Classico: Clear light red, bacon fat and roasted nuts on the nose, bright fruit with silky tannins.

2016 Felsina Winery Chianti Classico Riserva “Berardenga” Tuscany

 

 

Felsina is a thousand year old estate in the hills of Tuscany. The estate was bought in 1966 and turned into the present winery.

As a Riserva, the DOCG rules mandates that it must be aged a minimum of two years in barrel and three months in bottle before release.  

The Berardenga is one of several Chianti this estate produces from the Classico district. In addition to Classico, there are also seven sub-districts in Chianti; Arentini, Fiorentini, Senesi, Pisane, Montalbano, Montespertoli and Rufina. 

 

2016 Chianti Classico Riserva Berardenga

100% Sangiovese. Clear, medium red in color, classic nose of sweet violets, graphite, tar and leather, silky, tight tannins with some wood notes, firm acidity. Still hard edged at this point, needs some more time in the bottle.